Cohiba Magicos Maduro 5 Review: Full-Bodied Luxury in Every Puff

Brand: Cohiba

Line: Maduro 5

Size: 4.9 inches in length, 52-ring gauge

Wrapper: Cuban Maduro, aged for 5 years

Binder: Cuban

Filler: Cuban

Strength: Full-bodied

Price: £1,399 (box of 25 cigars)

The Cohiba Magicos Maduro 5 delivers a rich, bold flavor with its dark, 5-year-aged wrapper, perfect for a full-bodied smoke. Let’s dive into what makes this cigar one of my top choices.

Look & Feel: 18/20

The Cohiba Magicos Maduro 5 immediately catches my eye with its dark, oily maduro wrapper that’s been aged for five years, giving it an incredibly rich and elegant look. Right from the first touch, I can feel the quality in its solid construction – no soft spots anywhere. 

It has a nice weight in the hand, which tells me it’s well-packed with filler. With its 4.9-inch length and 52-ring gauge, it’s a balanced size that promises a full-bodied experience.

Pre-Light: 17/20

Before lighting, I take a moment to appreciate the aroma. It’s deep and rich, with inviting notes of cocoa, earth, and a subtle hint of spice. The cold draw is smooth and reveals a touch of sweetness along with some woodiness, giving me a preview of the complexity that’s to come. The pre-light aromas alone make me eager to get into this cigar.

Burn: 18/20

The Cohiba Magicos Maduro 5 offers an impressive burn, with a steady, even burn line throughout the smoke. The ash is firm and holds for a significant length before falling, showing the excellent construction of the cigar. The draw remains smooth from start to finish, providing a consistent flow of smoke without any issues.

Flavor: 19/20

As I smoke, the flavors unfold beautifully in three distinct phases, each bringing out different layers of richness:

• First Third: Right from the start, the cigar opens with bold notes of cocoa, espresso, and dark earth. I’m immediately struck by the powerful flavors – this cigar doesn’t hold back.
• Second Third: Moving into the second third, I notice the flavors deepening. The dark chocolate becomes more pronounced, and a touch of pepper comes through. There’s also a creamy texture developing, which adds a smoothness to the experience and makes each draw more refined. 
• Final Third: In the final third, the spice and leather notes come forward, while the sweetness fades into the background. The flavors stay bold, and the full-bodied strength really starts to kick in as I get closer to the finish. 

Each phase of the cigar offers something new, keeping the smoking experience interesting and complex.

Overall Experience: 18/20

The Cohiba Magicos Maduro 5 delivers a rich and bold experience, perfect for those who enjoy a full-bodied, flavorful smoke. The combination of its dark maduro wrapper, aged for 5 years, and the expertly blended Cuban filler and binder makes this a standout cigar.

Comparative Analysis

This is the comparison of cigars that I’ve found to offer a similar experience to the Cohiba Magicos Maduro 5. These cigars vary in size, strength, and flavor, providing a range of options depending on your preferences for rich, bold smokes or more balanced, medium-bodied ones.

The table highlights the construction quality and value, ensuring that you find the right cigar for your taste and occasion

Pairings

Here are three excellent pairings that elevate the experience of smoking the Cohiba Magicos Maduro 5:

• Aged Bourbon: The deep, caramel notes of aged bourbon beautifully enhance the cigar’s cocoa and dark chocolate flavors, creating a smooth and rich pairing that brings out the cigar’s natural sweetness.

• Espresso Martini: The bold coffee notes in an espresso martini perfectly complement the earthy, peppery undertones of the cigar, adding a creamy yet vibrant contrast that elevates both flavors.

• Salted Dark Chocolate: A piece of salted dark chocolate pairs wonderfully with the cigar’s robust and slightly sweet profile. The saltiness enhances the complexity of the cigar, making each puff even more satisfying.

Closing Insights

The Cohiba Magicos Maduro 5 is a cigar that truly stands out for its bold, rich flavors and impeccable construction. For me, the full-bodied profile, with its deep notes of cocoa, dark chocolate, and pepper, makes it a deeply indulgent experience – perfect for those who appreciate a cigar with real depth and complexity.

The luxurious touch of the 5-year-aged maduro wrapper shines through, and I love how the draw and burn remain consistently smooth from start to finish. It’s a satisfying smoke all the way through. That said, the cigar’s intensity might not suit everyone; its boldness can sometimes overshadow some of the more subtle flavors in the blend.

But despite this, I’d say that for seasoned smokers who enjoy a powerful, complex profile, the Cohiba Magicos Maduro 5 is an exceptional choice. Whether I’m celebrating a special occasion or just in the mood for something truly indulgent, this cigar feels top-tier and well worth savorin

James Peasley

James started out in the cigar industry in 2009, working for the leading cigar specialist in the UK for nearly a decade, slowly crafting his deep knowledge of cigars and developing a very refined palate. There's not many Cuban cigars he hasn't tasted, including Limited Edition Habanos and pre-embargo Davidoffs, as well as a large section of the New World offerings. When away from his desk he's usually found out walking in the countryside, or following other hot pursuits.