Cohiba Siglo I Review: A Jewel of Cuban Cigar Craftsmanship

Brand: Cohiba
Line: Siglo I
Size: 4 x 40
Wrapper: Cuban
Binder: Cuban
Filler: Cuban
Strength: Medium
Price: £499 (Box of 25)

For me, the Cohiba Siglo I is a standout in the Cohiba family, offering refined flavors and an elegant presentation – a perfect choice whether you’re a seasoned aficionado or new to premium cigars.

Look & Feel: 19/20

The Cohiba Siglo I is visually striking. The wrapper is a smooth, golden-brown color that shimmers in the light, indicating high-quality tobacco. The texture I noticed is silky and firm, with minimal veins that reflect the care taken in its production. The cigar felt to me substantial yet comfortable in hand, showcasing the skill of the roller.

Pre-Light: 17/20

The pre-light draw is smooth and effortless, giving me a hint of the quality tobacco inside. I pick up subtle notes of sweet cedar, a touch of leather, and a faint spice that intrigues the palate. These inviting aromas create anticipation for the flavors to come, reflecting the rich Cuban heritage behind this cigar. Even before lighting, the construction feels solid, promising a satisfying smoke ahead.

Burn: 18/20

Once lit, the Siglo I reveals its excellent construction, producing a rich, aromatic smoke from the first puff. The burn is consistently even, with a sharp line that needs minimal touch-ups. The ash is firm, holding well without flaking – a true testament to the quality and craftsmanship here. 

The smooth draw makes for a relaxed, enjoyable smoke, letting me focus on savoring the intricate flavors without interruptions for maintenance.

Flavor: 19/20

The flavor profile of the Cohiba Siglo I is where this cigar truly shines. It presents a well-balanced and complex array of flavors that unfold gradually throughout the smoking experience.

• First Third (0-30 minutes):

The first third introduces a delightful medley of flavors. Creamy cedar takes the forefront, accompanied by hints of leather that provide depth. The sweetness of dried fruits dances subtly on the palate, creating a smooth and inviting beginning. 

• Second Third (30-60 minutes):

As the Siglo I transitions into the second third, the flavors deepen and evolve beautifully. The body of the cigar becomes richer, with earthy tones taking center stage. The creaminess remains, but now it is complemented by dark chocolate and roasted coffee notes, which add complexity to the profile. 

• Final Third (60-90 minutes):

The final third of the Cohiba Siglo I is a culmination of the flavors experienced thus far. Sweetness from the first third re-emerges, accompanied by notes of caramel and toasted nuts, providing a delightful contrast to the earthiness. 

Overall Experience: 18/20

Siglo I’s exquisite construction, nuanced flavors, and elegant presentation make it a worthy choice for those who appreciate the finer things in life. 

The Siglo I is versatile enough to be enjoyed on various occasions, whether for a special celebration or a moment of personal indulgence. Its rich flavor profile encourages contemplation, making it a perfect companion for a relaxing evening.

Comparative Analysis

To provide context, let's compare the Cohiba Siglo I with other renowned Cuban cigars:

Pairings

To elevate the experience of the Siglo I, I would recommend these pairings that beautifully enhance its flavor profile:

• 7+ Year Aged Cuban Rum: The sweet, rich notes of a well-aged Cuban rum complement the cigar’s creamy and subtle fruity flavors, creating a delightful and harmonious pairing.
• Espresso: The bold intensity of espresso contrasts perfectly with the cigar’s smoothness, bringing out its nuanced flavors in a satisfying combination.
• 70% Dark Chocolate: The deep cocoa notes of dark chocolate add richness to the experience, amplifying the cigar’s natural sweetness and complexity.
• Highland Single Malt Whiskey: A fine Highland single malt whiskey enhances the cigar’s earthy undertones, creating a luxurious pairing that adds depth and sophistication.

Each pairing brings out unique elements in the Siglo I, making for a truly memorable smoke.

Final Thoughts

The Cohiba Siglo I earns a solid 91/100, a testament to its quality and craftsmanship. With its complexity, impeccable construction, and rich flavor profile, it stands out among premium Cuban cigars.

For me, enjoying a Siglo I is more than just smoking – it's immersing myself in Cuban tradition and artistry. Whether you’re a seasoned aficionado or new to cigars, this is one to savor. The Siglo I is a must-try for anyone seeking a refined, well-rounded experience, making it a standout addition to any collection.

James Peasley

James started out in the cigar industry in 2009, working for the leading cigar specialist in the UK for nearly a decade, slowly crafting his deep knowledge of cigars and developing a very refined palate. There's not many Cuban cigars he hasn't tasted, including Limited Edition Habanos and pre-embargo Davidoffs, as well as a large section of the New World offerings. When away from his desk he's usually found out walking in the countryside, or following other hot pursuits.