Montecristo No. 2 Review: Why It’s Often Regarded as the Best Cigar Ever Produced

Brand: Montecristo
Size: 6 1/8" x 52 (Torpedo)
Wrapper: Cuban
Binder: Cuban
Filler: Cuban
Strength: Medium to Full
Price: £906 (Box of 25)

Every time I light up a Montecristo No. 2, I’m reminded why it’s a go-to for so many cigar lovers. Let’s dive into what makes this cigar an unforgettable smoke.

Look & Feel: 19/20

This torpedo-shaped beauty is perfectly constructed, with a smooth, slightly oily wrapper that beckons you to light it up. The 6 1/8" length and 52-ring gauge provide a comfortable, substantial feel in hand, making it an appealing choice for both casual smokers and seasoned enthusiasts. 

The craftsmanship is evident in every detail, from the impeccable seams to the glossy finish of the wrapper.

Pre-Light: 18/20

As I prepared to light the Montecristo No. 2, the cold draw revealed earthy flavors of cedar, accompanied by a hint of sweetness. The aroma was rich and inviting, filled with notes of fresh hay and leather, promising an enjoyable smoking experience ahead. This initial assessment highlighted the cigar's complexity and foreshadowed the rich flavors to come.

Burn: 18/20

Upon lighting, the burn was slow and consistent, requiring minimal touch-ups throughout the smoke. The ash was sturdy, holding firm for a good portion of the cigar, which speaks to its high-quality construction. The draw remained effortless, producing a steady flow of smoke that enhanced the overall experience.

Flavor: 20/20

The flavor profile of the Montecristo No. 2 is nothing short of extraordinary, with each third of the cigar providing a unique journey of taste sensations.

• First Third (0-20 minutes):
  The cigar opens with rich flavors of coffee and chocolate, accented by a light spice that tickles the palate. The initial notes are bold yet balanced, making for an exciting start to the smoking experience.
• Second Third (20-40 minutes):
  As the cigar develops, richer notes of cedar and leather emerge, balanced by a touch of cocoa. This section is a delightful exploration of richness and complexity, showcasing the skillful blending of flavors that Montecristo is known for.
• Final Third (40-60 minutes):
  In the final third, stronger pepper and earthy tones emerge, with the sweetness of dark chocolate lingering on the finish. The smooth transition of flavors continues to impress, making the final moments of this cigar just as satisfying as the first.

Overall Experience: 20/20

The Montecristo No. 2 is a near-perfect cigar for those who appreciate complexity and boldness. it stands out due to its smooth transition of flavors, superb construction, and overall enjoyment. Whether you’re a seasoned aficionado or trying Cuban cigars for the first time, the Montecristo No. 2 is a must-try.

Comparative Analysis

To provide context on how the Montecristo No. 2 stacks up against other premium cigars, here’s a comparative analysis detailing size, price, strength, flavor profile, construction, and overall value.

In this comparison, the Montecristo No. 2 clearly holds its own against other prestigious cigars. Its balance of flavor and quality construction makes it a top choice for anyone seeking a refined smoking experience.

Pairings

To complement the Montecristo No. 2, I recommend the following pairings:

• Aged Cognac: The richness of aged cognac enhances the chocolate and spice notes of the cigar, creating a harmonious experience.
• Cuban Coffee: A robust cuban coffee balances the cigar's boldness, particularly enhancing the flavors in the final third.
• Dark chocolate: Enhances the earthy notes beautifully.

Final Verdict

The Montecristo No. 2 earns an exceptional score of 95/100. Its complexity, balance, and boldness make it one of the finest cigars Cuba has to offer. Whether celebrating a special occasion or indulging in a quiet evening, this cigar is always a winner.

For me, the Montecristo No. 2 is a perfect companion for relaxing and unwinding. While it’s not an everyday choice, it’s a cigar I turn to when I want something truly exceptional.

James Peasley

James started out in the cigar industry in 2009, working for the leading cigar specialist in the UK for nearly a decade, slowly crafting his deep knowledge of cigars and developing a very refined palate. There's not many Cuban cigars he hasn't tasted, including Limited Edition Habanos and pre-embargo Davidoffs, as well as a large section of the New World offerings. When away from his desk he's usually found out walking in the countryside, or following other hot pursuits.