Brand: Juan Lopez

Line: Seleccion Especial LCDH

Size: Robusto Extra (5 7/10 inches)

Wrapper: Cuban

Binder: Cuban

Filler: Cuban

Strength: Medium to Full

Price: £1,148 for a box of 25 cigars

Every time I light up a Juan Lopez Seleccion Especial, I’m reminded why it’s one of my favorites. Its flavors blend power with complexity. Let’s take a closer look at what makes it so special.

Look & Feel (16/20)

The Juan Lopez Seleccion Especial LCDH boasts a classic Cuban appearance, with its golden brown wrapper showing minor imperfections, such as visible veins. The construction is sturdy, though not flawless, with a slightly spongy feel in some spots.

Pre-Light (15/20)

On the pre-light draw, the cigar gives off earthy and slightly woody notes, with an understated aroma that doesn’t immediately captivate the senses. The cold draw is easy and reveals light notes of hay and toast. However, it lacks the complexity or richness found in more aromatic pre-light experiences.

Burn (14/20)

The burn performance of this cigar is where it falters slightly. Although it starts well, it can become uneven midway, requiring some touch-ups to maintain an even burn line. The ash is flaky at times, which might interrupt the enjoyment if you're expecting a consistent performance.

Flavor (17/20)

I noticed that the flavor of the Juan Lopez Seleccion Especial develops nicely, starting with rich, earthy tones accompanied by a hint of spice. As the cigar progresses, sweeter undertones of caramel and cocoa come through, adding a pleasant complexity.

First Third (10-20 minutes)

  • Rich, earthy tones
  • Hint of spice

Second Third: (20-40 minutes)

  • Sweeter undertones of caramel and cocoa
  • Increased complexity

Final Third: (40+ minutes)

  • Flavors don’t evolve significantly
  • Slightly less exciting finish

Overall Experience (16/20)

While the Juan Lopez Seleccion Especial LCDH offers a solid smoking experience, it may not fully meet the expectations set by its exclusivity. The flavors are enjoyable but lack the progression that would elevate it into a truly memorable cigar. 

Comparative Analysis

When I compare these cigars, the variety in size offers different experiences, from quick smokes to longer, more leisurely sessions. Some are priced affordably, while others command a higher price for their luxury and craftsmanship.

Cigar

Size

Price (approx.)

Strength

Flavor Profile

Construction

Value

Juan Lopez Seleccion Especial LCDH

Robusto Extra (5.7")

£1,148 (Box of 25)

Medium to Full

Rich, earthy tones with hints of spice and cocoa

Smooth, well-constructed, slightly spongy

High

Partagas Mille Fleurs

Petit Corona (5")

£296 (Box of 25)

Medium

Earthy, floral, with slight spice

Solid construction, even burn

Excellent for everyday smoke

Cohiba Esplendidos

Churchill (7")

£2,399 (Box of 25)

Medium to Full

Creamy with cocoa, vanilla, and spicy undertones

Flawless, consistent construction

Premium pricing, luxurious experience

Hoyo de Monterrey Epicure No. 2

Robusto (4.8")

£499 (Box of 25)

Medium

Light woody notes with creamy, sweet flavors

Great draw, consistently smooth

Good value for flavor complexity

Montecristo No. 2

Piramide (6.1")

£549 (Box of 25)

Medium to Full

Coffee, chocolate, and nutty richness

Well-crafted, solid burn

High—one of the most sought-after

Ramon Allones Specially Selected

Robusto (4.8")

£464 (Box of 25)

Full

Deep, rich tobacco flavors with spice and sweetness

Impeccable build, strong ash hold

High—great balance of flavor and strength

The flavor profiles cover a range from earthy and floral to rich coffee and spice notes, making each cigar unique depending on my mood. 

Pairings

Maximize the flavors of the Juan Lopez Seleccion Especial LCDH by indulging in these complementary pairings:

  • Dark Chocolate Stout: The rich, roasted malt flavors of a dark chocolate stout perfectly complement the cigar’s earthy and slightly spicy notes, while the creamy texture of the beer enhances the smoothness of the smoke.
  • Single Malt Scotch: A well-aged single malt with hints of oak, dried fruits, and light smokiness can beautifully balance the cigar's robust flavor, enhancing the peppery and cocoa undertones.
  • Spiced Tea: The warmth and complexity of spiced tea, especially blends with cinnamon and cardamom, pair wonderfully with the cigar's earthy and leathery notes, offering a comforting contrast to the smoke.

Bringing It All Together

After thoroughly enjoying the Juan Lopez Seleccion Especial LCDH, I’d rate this cigar a decent 82/100. It offers a rich, earthy profile with just the right amount of complexity from its spice and cocoa notes. 

While the burn and construction are generally good, it could benefit from more consistency in the final third, where the flavors don’t evolve as much as I hoped. 

Despite that, the medium-to-full strength and balanced flavors make it a great choice for any cigar lover who appreciates a classic Cuban smoke. This is definitely a cigar I'd keep in my humidor for special occasions, and it holds up well against other premium cigars in its category. Overall, a rewarding experience that’s worth revisiting.

Author Box
James Peasley

James Peasley

James started out in the cigar industry in 2009, working for the leading cigar specialist in the UK for nearly a decade, slowly crafting his deep knowledge of cigars and developing a very refined palate. There's not many Cuban cigars he hasn't tasted, including Limited Edition Habanos and pre-embargo Davidoffs, as well as a large section of the New World offerings. When away from his desk he's usually found out walking in the countryside, or following other hot pursuits.